A monopoly of education
Written by: Mark
January 18th, 2006There is no more denying it. The new school semester has started.
Katrina and I were watching 20/20 last Friday as they did a segment called “Stupid in America”. What an interesting title, don’t you think? The entire hour was dedicated to how students in the United States are not even close to measuring up to students of other countries. They focused on one child who was in the 7th grade at his local public high school, just getting by with passing grades…and didn’t even have a first grade reading level! That’s preposterous! Not necessarily for the child himself, but mainly that our school system is so laissez faire in demanding excellence from its students!
I’ve always known there were teacher’s unions; they always seemed pretty neutral to me - making sure teachers got paid enough (they don’t). However, this program was pushing for the unions to be abolished, calling them “monopolies in our children’s education”. Most kids are not legally able to choose where they go to school. They must be “zoned” to go where they live closest, keeping the poor kids in poor neighborhood schools, with older textbooks, older equipment…a second-hand education all around. When a monopoly is in force, everyone looses. Those within the monopoly feel no pressure to improve, since they already own the entire populous, and those outside the monopoly structure can’t choose any other options, inviting competition. Isn’t this what America was founded on? Isn’t it my right to choose what hamburger joint I pay for my dinner at? Isn’t it my right to choose what cell phone to buy? Just think of how competition has bettered the car industry! We’d still be driving Model-T’s if Henry Ford owned the market.
Anyone with all the cards in their hand won’t be internally motivated to improve their cards - and they’ll win the hand every time! Why not give kids the choice of where to go to school? That’s what happens in college, and look at how universities are fighting each other for your attendance: study abroad programs, cutting-edge technology, best professors in the world… Why not give kids a school voucher, allowing them to attend the school of their choice? What sorts of amazing “products of education” might they become?


