Book Review: Colors of God

Colors of God: Conversations about Being the Church written by Randall Mark Peters, Dave Phillips, and Quentin Steen is a breeze to read through – but doesn’t touch on much that has been covered in other similar books.
This is the second book in as many months that I’ve read in a “dialogging style” meaning the authors write their content out like a script, a la “Peter: text text text…. Quentin: response response response…”  If you’ve read John Perkins’ and Shane Claiborne’s new book Follow Me to Freedom, you know what I’m talking about.  Personally, I found this type of book one of the hardest and most frustrating to read.  It seems like a thinly-veiled attempted to start a conversation that we’re not really able to participate in.  Honestly, I’d rather them craft a singular voice, rather than splicing together a few conference calls they had.
Okay – so they lose a few points for style, but they make up for it in content! Â They bring up some thoughtful points around issues they believe are major theological elephants in the room at most churches. Â They use a fairly pointless metaphor of “colors” to bring these issues up – Blue = the Gospel (do we see the Gospel for all it is?) Green = Healthy Living (does our theology promote life and health or bitterness and death?) Red = Inclusive Community (how does our church involve folks interested in associating with us?) and Yellow = Cultural Engagement (we need to go to R rated movies).
I suppose the underlying premise of this book is that if we just tweaked our understanding of these issues, the church would be “fixed!” Â There is some truth that when you learn new realities, you begin to change your behavior. Â But too much head knowledge doesn’t necessarily shift to new tangible realities. Â I’d rather see us focus the Colors of God on what the Gospel is doing in practice in their church. Â If I could hear their stories of how this theology of a radical Gospel is affecting how the members of their church changes how they treat their mailman or how they approach world issues, I think the book might have held my attention.
There were some scandalous statements sprinkled throughout the pages.  They dance around the issue of “universal salvation” around the pointlessness of “confessing your sins” and other tenets held dear by most churches – but they answer most concerns in a FAQ chapter for each Color.  For instance, to counter the accusation of a “universalist” label, they answer in their “Red FAQ” that the the salvation is offered to everyone, but not everyone takes it – they’d rather stay out of God’s inclusive community – but they put a little twist on that saying that most folks who refuse to come around God’s inclusive community will be the religious elite!
Simply stated, there just wasn’t much grabbing me in this text – I’d say its a skim – especially if you are a pastor at a church, wondering what major “roots” lay at the heart of why in their congregation there is so much guilt, so much exclusivity and pride, and so many remain secluded from their culture – this book may offer some deeper theological insight.
Now, aside from the text itself – I’m thankful there are guys like Peters, Phillips and Steen willing to be brave enough to challenge the conventional approaches taken by much of evangelicalism in our world today.  We need only MORE of this dialogue…giving people legs to stand on as they question assumptions and move out into new territories in faith.  A spirit of inquisitiveness and bravery was quite refreshing as I read through the book.  If you’ve never read other books of this type (and there are quickly becoming TOO many in our bookstores these days…) then pick it up and let them take you for a drive.  You’ll thank them for it.

Jay Abels 11:33 pm on January 28, 2010 Permalink
Wouldn’t it be nice if there were just some guarantees and a system that always worked, when you did it right. But, we would loose the excitement of seeing God work and experiencing growth.
Rachael 12:07 pm on January 29, 2010 Permalink
These are great, Mark! I can tell you from me and Stephen’s experience the last year and a half in a more traditional church that all of these same concepts apply
Our church would be much more authentic, spiritual and more successful if everyone was able to remember these things…
Mark 12:22 pm on January 29, 2010 Permalink
Rachael — Thanks for the input! Very truly, people are people, no matter how or where they meet. I agree with you that if we can trust each other enough to take off our masks, we can experience the healing that God intends for us. I appreciate you guys for your willingness to be real with those in the church, and out of it.
Jay — Ha, its true. So quickly and easily do I reduce “EVERYTHING” down to “five unmovable principles” or “three easy to follow steps.” Pour, mix, serve. Voila!~ “Church!” Not so fast… your comment is a good reminder that not even these 5 principles are a guarantee that God’s Spirit will take ahold of a group! Good thoughts.
Jay 8:34 pm on February 11, 2010 Permalink
I remember the first time I dug up a little plot and planted some vegetable seeds. They just didn’t grow according to my time schedule. I managed to pull up a few little carrots trying to speed their growth. Now it is funny, until I think about maybe having uprooted some young Christians who have just sprouted. He gives the increase, but not on our timeline.
Mark G Willis 9:27 am on February 12, 2010 Permalink
Very sobering Jay – regarding the gardening metaphor – I think you might find this OLD video of Frog and Toad interesting!
http://godgrown.net/blog/2007/10/03/frog-toad-and-organic-growth/